Painting 33

Combination of médium techniques

I do not follow rules I try to paint every new painting in a way that is relatively different from the previous, so I try texture in different ways, then I combine different techniques in the same painting, In other words I´m trying to find a different approch to fit my feeling to attack the different themes I´m working with. 
In the following painting ref PO633 the background was given with colored yesso impasto and above that I added acrylic color keeping the ligth áreas as much as posible
Another point I´m trying along this excersize is to mix at least two or more colors before and/or onto the canvas in order to convey transparency and refraction of color and shape. the whole combination of reflection and strong contrast is a challenge itself.
The first picture of this painting has been done ,just  after apply acrylic ,
The second one; after apply oil painting transparencies to give more contrast but keeping the ligthest áreas as much as posible
Which is the one wich shown more real feeling?

                                      Ref PO633 picture 1

 

PO634 picture 2(after modify)